By Carol Herman
November 6, 2005
After placing ads seeking subjects in newspapers
"Have you been abducted by aliens?" numerous calls came in. Most of the calls
were from local TV stations, radio shows, and newspapers curious to know why
Harvard was interested in aliens. Some were from ticked-off Bostonians ("Doesn't
Harvard have better ways to spend all its [darn] money?") A few painful calls
came from Latin Americans who misunderstood the ads and thought we were looking
for illegal immigrants abducted by U.S. border patrols. One call was from an
alien. After the beep, there was silence. As I hovered in the doorway, the
machine emitted a static-like sound, followed by about twenty seconds of
punctuated atonal beeping. There was an eerie syntax, almost a cadence, to the
noise, and it ended with a prolonged hissssssssss. It was no less creepy the
tenth time I played it . . . ."
Ms Clancy is a witty writer, and that provides a pleasant counterpoint to what she discovers along the course of her research, starting with a phenomenon called "sleep paralysis," an experience in which people wake up for a few moments and find themselves unable to move. Ms. Clancy writes that "About 20 percent of the population has had at least one episode of this type accompanied by hallucinations." Compounding this phenomenon is hypnosis, a technique that people who have encountered the inexplicable often turn to, along with therapy. Trouble is that hypnotism, can make these people subject to suggestions that only compound their difficulties. Rather than providing insight into their experiences, hypnosis can add to their troubles.
One subject reports, "In my first energy session, I was asked to relax and was put into a trance state. What was weird is that I was expecting to see my grandmother abusing me and instead, all of a sudden, I see a ship hovering outside my window . . . I see creatures walking toward the house."
So who are these abductees ? Ms. Clancy writes, "It depends. If I compare them to the well-educated readers of university press books like this one, then the abductees are about 1.5 standard deviations from the norm, on a continuum I'll tentatively label 'weirdness.' But if I compare them to other groups I've had close contact with -- serious vegetarians, yoga enthusiasts, artists, Hollywood actors, psychologists, Internet entrepreneurs, or my family -- they really don't look all that different."
Ms. Clancy is particularly adept at showing how popular culture, particularly movies and television have influenced reports of alien abduction. She writes "[alien abduction reports] began only after they were featured on TV and in the movies. Abduction accounts did not exist prior to 1962 (UFOs did and aliens in space did, but aliens coming to Earth to abduct humans did not.")
I have a friend, the soul of probity for the most part, who claims to have seen a UFO during the war. His wife, at a different time, saw something else that to her mind could only be explained as something from outer space. It could be that with enough research into those past events, some logical explanation might be found. Or not. But alien abduction Ms. Clancy's writes, "is one of the possible plots that cannot be objectively verified . . . ." Alien abductions work really well because no one can say for sure that they didn't happen, and questions like 'How did you float through the door?' or 'Why didn't anyone else see the space ship?' can be answered with appeals to the aliens' technological superiority."
Alien abduction is clearly a maddening phenomenon. Nevertheless, Ms. Clancy soldiered on -- for the benefit of science, the subjects and now her readers. And apart from some brisk and debatable observations about religion that pop up at the end, she has done all a service. This book is something else.