|
June 27, 2000
Irish
Independent
UFOs, is the truth out there?
UFOs once the preserve of the purely paranoid are now being taken
seriously. Astronauts, Generals and a number of influential scientists are
hammering away at the crust of international scepticism. LESLIE KEAN
explains why a study by the French military may finally make governments
sit up and take notice.
The release in April of the first detailed satellite images of Area 51,
the top-secret Air Force test site in Nevada, prompted a website meltdown
as people from around the world searched for clues about unidentified
flying objects.
The interest has been really phenomenal, said David Mountain, marketing
director for Aerial Images, Inc which posted the high resolution aerial
photos of Area 51 on the Internet.
But those hoping to see signs of something extraordinary were destined to
be disappointed. Most of Area 51s operations occur underground, making
photos meaningless. Anyone looking for the fresh information on UFOs would
have better luck trying a new, but less publicized source: by the French
military, just translated into English.
High level officials including retired generals from the French Institute
of Higher Studies for National Defense, a government-funded strategic
planning agency recently took a giant step in openly challenging
skepticism about UFOs. In a report based on a three year study, they
concluded that, numerous manifestations observed by reliable witnesses
could be the work of craft of extra-terrestrial origin and that, in fact,
the best explanation is the extraterrestrial hypothesis.
Although not categorically proven, strong presumptions exist in its favor
and if it is correct, it is loaded with significant consequences.
The French group reached that conclusion after examining nearly 500
detailed international aeronautical sightings and radar/visual cases, and
previously undisclosed pilots reports. They drew on data from official
sources, government authorities, and the Air Forces of different
countries.
The findings are contained in a 90-page report titled, UFOs and Defense:
What Should We Prepare For?, published in France by the magazine VSD.
The mechanics of a mystery. The number of sightings, which are completely
unexplained despite the abundance and quality of data from them, is
growing throughout the world, the team declared.
The authors note that about 5 percent of sightings on which there is solid
documentation cannot be easily attributed to earthly sources, such as
secret military exercises - especially since unexplained objects have been
reported since 1944. The rest seem to be completely unknown flying
machines with exceptional performances that are guided by a natural or
artificial intelligence, they say.
Science has developed plausible models for travel from another solar
system and for technology which could be used to propel the vehicles, the
report says. assures readers that UFOs have demonstrated no hostile acts,
although intimidation maneuvers have been confirmed.
Given the widespread scepticism about UFOs, many will quickly dismiss the
generals ET hypothesis. But it is less easy to do so once the authors
credentials are considered.
The study's originators are four-star General Bernard Norlain, former
commander of the French Tactical Air Force and military counselor to the
prime minister; General Denis Letty, an air force fighter pilot; and Andre
Lebeau, former head of the National Center for Space Studies (the French
equivalent of NASA in the United States.)
They formed a 12-member Committee for In-depth Studies, abbreviated as
COMETA, which authored the report. Three-star Admiral Marc Merlo, national
chief of police Denis Blancher and Jean-Jacques Velasco, head of a
government agency studying UFOs, as well as scientists and weapons
engineers, were also contributors. Not only does the group stand by its
findings, it is urging international action.
The writers recommend that France establish sectorial cooperation
agreements with interested European and foreign countries on the matter of
UFOs. They suggest that the European Union undertake diplomatic action
with the United States exerting useful pressure to clarify this crucial
issue which must fall within the scope of political and strategic
alliances.
Why might other nations be inclined to take this subject seriously? For
one thing, declassified US government documents show that unexplained
objects with extraordinary technical capabilities pose challenges to
military activity around the globe. For example, US fighter jets have been
scrambled to pursue UFOs, according to North American Aerospace Defense
Command logs and US Air Force documents.
Iranian and Peruvian Air Force planes attempted to shoot down unexplained
objects during air encounters in 1976 and 1980, and Belgian F-16s equipped
with automatically guided missiles pursued UFOs in 1990.
Further, the French report says that there have been visits above secret
installations and missile bases and military aircraft shadowed in the US.
Dr. Edgar Mitchell, the Apollo 14 astronaut who was the sixth man to walk
on the moon, is one of many supporters of international cooperation on
UFOs. Of the French report, he says, It's significant that individuals of
some standing in the government, military and intelligence community in
France came forth with this.
Mitchell, who holds a doctor of science degree from the prestigious
Massachusetts Institute of Technology, is convinced at a confidence level
above 90pc, that there is reality to all of this. He adds, People have
been digging through the files and investigating for years now. The files
are quite convincing. The only thing that's lacking is the official stamp.
He joins five-star Admiral Lord Hill-Norton, the former head of the
British Ministry of Defense, in calling for US congressional fact-finding
hearings into the UFO question.
Hearings would include testimony by government witnesses from the Air
Force, Army, Navy, NASA, private industry and intelligence operations with
personal, first-hand knowledge of UFO phenomena and related projects.
The astronaut amd the investigation Despite the fact that Mitchell is a
national hero and has been honoured with the Presidential Medal of
Freedom, the USN Distinguished Service Medal and the NASA Distinguished
Service Medal, his request for an investigation has been ignored by U.S.
officials.
Nonetheless, the public's interest in UFOs is undiminished. A ballot
initiative underway in the US state of Missouri, and certified by the
secretary of state in March, urges Congress to convene hearings. The
initiative states that the Federal Governments handling of the UFO issue
has contributed to the public cynicism toward, and general mistrust of,
government.
US Naval Reserve Commander Willard H. Miller has been communicating this
same concern to high level officials for a number of years. With over 30
years in Navy and Joint Interagency operations with the US Defense
Department, Miller has participated in a series of previously undisclosed
briefings for Pentagon brass about military policy regarding UFOs.
Like many, he says he worries that the military's lack of preparation for
encounters with unexplained craft could provoke a dangerous confrontation
when, and if, such an encounter occurs; precipitous military decisions, he
warns, may lead to unnecessary confusion, misapplication of forces, or
possible catastrophic consequences.
And he says he is not alone in his concerns. There are those in high
places in the government who share a growing interest in this subject,
Miller reports.
Miller retired in 1994 from active duty on the Current Operations Staff
(J3) of U.S. Atlantic Command, Norfolk, Virginia where he worked
operations, intelligence, and special contingency issues. In a February,
2000 confidential memo prepared for this reporter, he spelled out the
details of meetings with named officials - including the Director of the
Defense Intelligence Agency, an Admiral on the Joint Staff, and the U.S.
Atlantic Command's Director for Intelligence - between 1989 and 2000.
Miller concurs with the COMETA's observation that there is no evidence of
hostility from UFOs The only threat to the national security of the United
States is the continued denial of undeniable physical UFO occurrences and
sightings to a public growing increasingly frustrated with its
government's weak explanations, Miller says.
Air Force Regulation 200-2, Unidentified Flying Objects Reporting,
prohibits the release to the public and the media any data about those
objects which are not explainable while allowing disclosure only of the
UFOs that have been identified as familiar objects.
An even more restrictive procedure is outlined in the Joint Army Navy Air
Force Publication 146, which provides communications instructions for
reporting sightings relevant to US security. Anyone under its jurisdiction
disclosing reports without authorization is subject to prosecution under
the Espionage Act.
Even the President of the United States recently had trouble accessing
information on the subject. In 1995, philanthropist Laurence Rockefeller
provided UFO briefing materials to President Clinton, Hillary Clinton, and
Presidential science advisor Jack Gibbons while they spent a weekend at
Rockefeller's Wyoming ranch. Clinton then instructed Associate Attorney
General at the Justice Department, Webster Hubbell, to investigate the
existence of UFOs, as disclosed by Hubbell in his book, Friends in High
Places. Despite this request from the Commander in Chief, Hubbell was
unable to obtain information on the subject.
In earlier decades, issues that remain pertinent today were openly
discussed. In 1960, for example, US Representative Leonard G. Wolf of Iowa
entered an urgent warning from R.E. Hillenkoetter, a former CIA Director
and Navy vice admiral, into the Congressional Record that certain dangers
are linked with unidentified flying objects.
Wolf cited Gen. L.M. Chassin, NATO coordinator of Allied Air Service,
warning that If we persist in refusing to recognize the existence of the
UFOs, we will end up, one fine day, by mistaking them for the guided
missiles of an enemy - and the worst will be upon us.
These concerns were taken seriously enough to be incorporated into the
1971 Agreement on Measures to Reduce the Outbreak of Nuclear War between
the US and the Soviet Union. The treaty states that the two countries will
notify each other immediately in the event of detection by missile warning
systems of unidentified objects...if such occurrences could create a risk
of outbreak of nuclear war between the two countries.
The French report may open the door for nations to be more forthcoming
once again. Chile, for example, is openly addressing it's own concerns
about air safety and UFOs. The now retired Chief of the Chilean Air Force
has formed a committee with civil aviation experts to study recent near
collisions between UFOs and civilian airliners.
As the international conversation about UFOs unfolds, sightings continue,
as they have for decades. Perhaps the most notable recent US sighting took
place in March 1997. Hundreds of people across the state of Arizona
reported seeing huge triangular objects, hovering silently in the night
sky - a sighting that, as the state's Senator John McCain noted recently,
has never been fully explained.
As recently as Jan. 5, 2000, four policemen at different locations in St.
Claire County, Illinois, witnessed a huge, brightly lighted, triangular
craft flying and hovering at 1000 feet. One officer reported witnessing
extreme rapid motion by the craft that cannot be explained in conventional
terms. Nearby Scott Air Force base and the FAA purport to know nothing.
The French Institute of Higher Studies for National Defense and the
National Center for Space Studies remain several steps ahead of the United
States military and NASA. Perhaps the report by the bold French generals
-- with its goal of stripping the phenomenon of UFOs of its irrational
layer will be a catalyst for authorities around the world to publicly
examine the issue of UFOs in a new light.
|